ECE
4810 ELECTRICAL/COMPUTER ENGINEERING DESIGN I
Spring
2012
version 12 April 2012
Important Note:
This
document is available at http://homepages.wmich.edu/~miller/ECE4810.html and provides
critical resources for this course, including a schedule, homework assignments,
handouts, hyperlinked materials, etc. Check the posted version for updates.
Instructor:
Dr. Damon A. Miller, Associate Professor of Electrical and Computer
Engineering, Western Michigan University, College of Engineering and Applied
Sciences, Parkview Campus, Room A-240, 269.276.3158, 269.276.3151 (fax), damon.miller@wmich.edu,
www.homepages.wmich.edu/~miller/.
Course Coordinators:
Dr. John Gesink (john.gesink@wmich.edu) and
Dr. Damon A. Miller (damon.miller@wmich.edu)
Course
Development and Acknowledgements:
Dr. Gesink developed and
collected much of the material used in this course. Dr. Daniel M. Litynski (dan.litynski@wmich.edu) has also contributed course improvements. Your
comments are welcome. Some course notes (including figures) may be verbatim
from course texts.
Office
Hours:
Office hours are posted on Dr. Miller’s door and at http://homepages.wmich.edu/~miller/.
Please respect course instructor office hours.
Other times are available by appointment.
WMU
Catalog Description:
ECE 4810
Electrical/Computer Engineering Design I (1--3), 2 hrs. First of a two-semester
sequence on engineering design in which students work in teams on approved
design projects. A preliminary design is expected at the conclusion of this
course. This course and ECE 4820 are approved as writing-intensive courses
which may fulfill the baccalaureate-level writing requirement of the student's
curriculum. Prerequisites: IME 3160; consent of department
chair.
Consent of the department chair is obtained by completion of an
application to enroll in ECE 4810 and is based on:
1.
completion of IME
3160/ECE 3550 or ECE 4510 (for CpE students);
2.
completion of ECE 2510/IME
3160/ECE 3200 or ECE 3300 (for EE students); and an
3.
ability to work
independently and as part of a design team, accepting responsibility for
specific portions of a design project.
Project Constraints:
In short, senior design
projects must be entirely “open”.
Course Tasks and
Description:
Students will be responsible for selecting a design project,
forming a three-person design team, and for writing a formal proposal, which
describes the project as well as its implementation. The designed device or
system will be constructed in ECE 4820 based on this proposal. Lectures and
assignments will examine topics relating to engineering design such as needs
and specifications, patents, feasibility, engineering design methodology,
project scheduling, and human factors engineering. Students will explore topics
critical to the practice of engineering, including engineering ethics,
intellectual property, and professional registration. Written communication skills are also
emphasized throughout the course. Each
student is urged to keep a permanently bound journal/log/lab notebook in which
individual contributions to the design proposal are recorded. Students are required to attend all seminars
as noted in the course schedule, all ECE 4810 class meetings, and are required
to register with the WMU Career Services office (See Bronco Jobs at http://www.wmich.edu/career/).
Department and Course
Level Learning Outcomes:
Department Level
Learning Outcomes1:
Graduates must have:
a.
an ability to apply
knowledge of mathematics, science, and engineering;
b.
an ability to design and
conduct experiments, as well as to analyze and interpret data;
c.
an ability to design a
system, component, or process to meet desired needs2;
d.
an ability to function
on multi-disciplinary teams;
e.
an ability to identify,
formulate, and solve engineering problems;
f.
an ability to understand
professional and ethical responsibility;
g.
an ability to
communicate effectively;
h.
a broad education
necessary to understand the impact of engineering solutions in a global and
societal context;
i.
a recognition of the
need for, and an ability to engage in, life-long learning;
j.
a knowledge of
contemporary issues; and
k.
an ability to use
techniques, skills, and modern engineering tools necessary for engineering
practice and/or further graduate study.
In addition to these learning outcomes ECE 4810/20 is designed to contribute
to the professional component3
(PC) of the student's education.
1The following is adapted (with only slight
modification) from the Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology
(ABET) Engineering Criteria 2000, Criteria for Accrediting Engineering:
Criterion 3. Program
Outcomes and Assessment Engineering programs must demonstrate that their
graduates have: (a) an ability to apply knowledge of mathematics, science, and engineering
(b) an ability to design and conduct experiments, as well as to analyze and
interpret data (c) an ability to design a system, component, or process to meet
desired needs (d) an ability to function on multi-disciplinary teams (e) an
ability to identify, formulate, and solve engineering problems (f) an
understanding of professional and ethical responsibility (g) an ability to
communicate effectively (h) the broad education necessary to understand the
impact of engineering solutions in a global and societal context (i) a
recognition of the need for, and an ability to engage in life-long learning (j)
a knowledge of contemporary issues (k) an ability to use the techniques, skills,
and modern engineering tools necessary for engineering practice.
2Definition directly from the Annual Report of
the ABET circa 1992-93:
(3) Engineering Design.
(a) Engineering design is the process of devising a system, component, or
process to meet desired needs. It is a decision-making
process (often iterative), in which the basic sciences, mathematics, and
engineering sciences are applied to convert resources optimally to meet a
stated objective. Among the fundamental
elements of the design process are the establishment of objectives and
criteria, synthesis, analysis, construction, testing, and evaluation. The engineering design component of a
curriculum must include at least some of the following features: development of
student creativity, use of open-ended problems, development and use of modern
design theory and methodology, formulation of design problem statements and specifications,
consideration of alternative solutions, feasibility considerations, production
processes, concurrent engineering design, and detailed system
descriptions. Further, it is essential
to include a variety of realistic constraints such as economic factors, safety,
reliability, aesthetics, ethics, and social impact.
3The following is taken from the ABET Engineering
Criteria 2000, Criteria for Accrediting Engineering:
Criterion 4.
Professional Component. The professional component requirements specify subject
areas appropriate to engineering but do not prescribe specific courses. The
engineering faculty must assure that the program curriculum devotes adequate
attention and time to each component, consistent with the objectives of the
program and institution. Students must be prepared for engineering practice through
the curriculum culminating in a major design experience based on the knowledge
and skills acquired in earlier course work and incorporating engineering
standards and realistic constraints that include most of the following
considerations: economic; environmental; sustainability; manufacturability;
ethical; health and safety; social; and political. The professional component must include (a) one
year of a combination of college level mathematics and basic sciences (some
with experimental experience) appropriate to the discipline (b) one and
one-half years of engineering topics, consisting of engineering sciences and
engineering design appropriate to the student's field of study (c) a general
education component that complements the technical content of the curriculum and
is consistent with the program and institution objectives.
ECE 4810 Course
Learning Outcomes
The course level learning outcomes contribute to the departmental
learning outcomes as indicated below. The relevance of specific course
activities to the departmental learning objectives is indicated in the course
schedule at the end of the syllabus.
Graduates of ECE 4810 must have:
1.
an appreciation of the
importance of using notebooks to document engineering research and development
work (ABET: g);
2.
an ability to develop a
needs analysis (ABET: a,c,e,h,j);
3.
a working knowledge of
the sources of engineering design specifications (e.g. consumers, companies,
groups having authority) (ABET: c,e);
4.
an ability to develop a
comprehensive set of quantitative and qualitative engineering design
specifications based on a needs analysis (ABET: a,c,e,h,j);
5.
an ability to apply and
understand the advantages and disadvantages of the three primary methods of
engineering design: synthesis, repeated analysis, and device evolution (ABET:
a,c,e,k);
6.
an ability to conduct a
physical and economic feasibility study for a proposed device or system (ABET:
a,b,c,e,k);
7.
an ability to conduct a
literature and patent search to support an engineering design project (ABET:
a,b,c,e,k);
8.
an ability to design a
device or system to meet a specified need using knowledge of mathematics,
science, and engineering, while considering (as listed by ABET Engineering
Criteria 2000) “economic; environmental; sustainability; manufacturability;
ethical; health and safety; social; and political” issues (ABET:
a,b,c,e,h,j,k);
9.
an ability to
effectively function as a member of a design team (ABET: c,d,g);
10.
an ability to develop a
strategy for designing a device or system based on a precedence matrix (ABET:
a,b,c,e,k);
11.
an ability to use
physical and/or mathematical models to verify that a designed device or system
satisfies the design specifications (ABET: a,b,c,e,k);
12.
an ability to provide
effective documentation for an engineering design project (ABET: g);
13.
an ability to estimate
time needed to complete an engineering project using the critical math method
and the program evaluation and review technique (ABET: c,k);
14.
a knowledge of the role
that human factors engineering has in engineering design (ABET: a,c);
15.
an ability to determine
the tolerance on a device or system based on the tolerances of the individual
components comprising that device or system (ABET: a,c,e,k);
16.
a basic understanding of
mechanisms to protect intellectual property, including patents, copyrights,
trademarks, semiconductor masks, and trade secrets (ABET: c,e,k);
17.
an understanding and
appreciation of engineering ethics, including an ability to cite examples where
engineering ethics were compromised with disastrous consequences (ABET: f);
18.
a knowledge of the IEEE
and the NSPE Code of Ethics (ABET: f);
19.
an understanding of the
importance of, and how to obtain, a professional engineering license (ABET: f);
20.
an appreciation for the
role engineers play in society (ABET: f,h,i,j);
21.
an awareness of basic
electronic system prototyping techniques (ABET: k);
22.
and an ability to correctly
and effectively communicate via the written word (ABET: d,g,k).
Textbook
and Materials:
Required:
Recommended:
http://libguides.wmich.edu/engineeringhttp://libguides.wmich.edu/engineering
b.
ASTM STANDARDS
http://libproxy.library.wmich.edu/login?url=http://enterprise.astm.org/
http://libguides.wmich.edu/engineering
j.
Computer
Science Subject Guide
http://libguides.wmich.edu/compsci
a. The MathWorks®,
MATLAB® & SIMULINK® (student version). This is a tremendous value as this package
includes many toolboxes and blocksets that must be purchased separately for use
in a professional version. Use this opportunity to learn MATLAB®;
this is one of the most widely used software packages, especially in electrical
engineering.
b. Wolfram Research,
Mathematica®. This is
a remarkable, unified symbolic
approach to computing. Visit http://www.mathematica.com/
to see some of the extraordinary capabilities of this package developed by Stephen Wolfram.
c.
MapleSoft®,
MapleTM, available on main campus.
References:
Source of Potential Support:
1. http://www.ti.com/corp/docs/landing/universityprogram/
Other:
1. Valuable resource for help with written
communication skills: WMU Writing Center: http://www.wmich.edu/casp/writingcenter/ (Ellsworth Hall, room 1343)
2.
See http://www.wmich.edu/engineer/events.htm
for events in the WMU College of Engineering and Applied Sciences.
3.
Hyperlinks are provided later in this
document for resources related to engineering design, vendors, engineering
ethics, etc.
4.
“Preparation of
Papers for IEEE Transactions and
Journals (May 2007),”
use as example of how to format references.
Course Documents and Forms:
Links:
Course Policies
Academic
Honesty
General:
“You
are responsible for making yourself aware of and understanding the policies and
procedures in the Undergraduate and Graduate Catalogs that pertain to Academic
Honesty. These policies include cheating, fabrication, falsification and
forgery, multiple submission, plagiarism, complicity and computer misuse. [The
policies can be found at http://catalog.wmich.edu under Academic Policies, Student
Rights and Responsibilities.] If there is reason to believe you have been
involved in academic dishonesty, you will be referred to the Office of Student
Conduct. You will be given the opportunity to review the charge(s). If you
believe you are not responsible, you will have the opportunity for a hearing.
You should consult with your instructor if you are uncertain about an issue of
academic honesty prior to the submission of an assignment or test.” —
provided by the Professional Concerns Committee of the WMU Faculty Senate
Plagiarism:
“One
of the most serious academic offenses is plagiarism (see definition for
"plagiarize" in the Cambridge Advanced Learner's
Dictionary). If your institution, colleagues, or professional organization
believe that you have unfairly used the work (the intellectual property) of
another person, you may lose your job, be asked to leave your university,
and/or have your professional career ruined” [from http://www.ohio.edu/linguistics/info/plagiarism.html]. See that website for tutorials on how to
insure that you never plagiarize another’s work.
Grading
Basis
|
Project
Proposal (written) |
40% |
|
Proposal
Preparation Process and Homework |
15% |
|
Examination
and Quizzes (announced or unannounced) |
45% |
|
Penalty
for avoidable non-3-person team |
15% |
OUTSTANDING
WORK might earn extra credit. Incorrect
assignments may be returned for rework and resubmission. Critical assignments
must be satisfactorily completed to earn a passing grade. The first student to
report an error in any material prepared by the course instructor will earn
extra credit.
Scale: 0-60 E | 60-65 D | 65-70 DC | 70-75 C | 75-80
CB | 80-85 B | 85-90 BA | 90-100 A |
Class attendance is required and might be factored into the final
class score. A
midterm grade, if assigned, serves only as an indication of your progress in
the course, and should not be used as an indicator of your final grade.
Fundamentals
of Engineering (FE) Examination
Students that take the FE exam during this semester will earn a 10%
credit added to their final grade. Proof of examination attendance attached to
a memo submitted to the course instructor by the Wednesday of final exam week is
required to earn this credit. See http://www.ncees.org for the
examination registration deadline and test date. Students that have already
passed this examination are eligible for this credit. Note that the FE exam is offered 14 April 2012 and that the registration
deadline is 23 February 2012. Double check this information on your own!
EXAMINATIONS AND
QUIZZES
will be closed-notes and closed-book unless otherwise noted. You must have a
WMU issued ID with you at the exam.
Only
under extremely unusual circumstances will make-up examinations and quizzes be
considered. If an emergency prevents you
from attending a scheduled examination or quiz, contact your instructor PRIOR
to the test or as soon as you can reach a telephone, e-mail terminal, etc. If
the instructor cannot be reached directly, leave a message with the department
(276-3150). Failure to adhere to this
policy will result in zero credit for the exercise.
Use
of Calculators
When
a calculator is allowed on a quiz/exam, without
exception only models accepted by the Fundamentals of Engineering
Examination may be used; see http://www.ncees.org/Exams/FE_exam/Calculator_policy.php
for a list of approved calculators.
HOMEWORK will be assigned regularly. Some of it will be
collected and evaluated. Collected homework should normally be done on 8 1/2''
by 11'' sheets. “Engineer's Pad” sheets
are preferred. Solutions must be done in a neat, structured, logical, and
orderly manner with frequent brief notations enabling the grader to readily
verify the author's source of information, steps taken, sources of formula,
equations, and methods used. (USE THE PARTIAL CHECK LIST FOR HOMEWORK SUBMITTED
FOR EVALUATION below). Papers failing to
meet these guidelines may not be graded and may be returned, with or without an
opportunity for resubmission with a penalty. LATE HOMEWORK will not be
accepted, except under extraordinary circumstances.
For reading assignments, submit a
signed and dated statement “I certify that I have read [reading assignment
here] in its entirety” as part of the homework to be turned in. For websites,
use a statement “I certify that I have substantially explored [website address
here]”.
PARTIAL CHECK LIST FOR HOMEWORK SUBMITTED FOR EVALUATION:
The author's sense of professional pride should be discernible
from the manner of information presentation.
Electronic
Devices
Electronic devices are to be turned off (unless there is a safety issue) during
lecture unless arrangements have been made with the instructor.
Course SCHEDULE
Schedule subject to change.
Additional Friday class meetings might be scheduled. All homework assignments
are to be completed individually except as noted. Religious observances will be
accommodated with advanced notice.
|
class # |
date |
topic |
|
WEEK 1 |
||
|
1 |
1/9 |
course introduction TURN IN EACH HOMEWORK
AS A SEPARATE STAPLED PACKET WITH A COVER PAGE HW #1 DUE 1/18 Note: for reading assignments you must SIGN
the statement “I
certify that I have read [reading assignment here] in its entirety” if
applicable to receive credit. Note: for
websites you must SIGN the statement “I certify that I have substantially
explored [website address here]” if applicable to receive credit. 1. Read syllabus 2. Read Middendorf CH 1.1-1.2 and CH 3 3.
Read sections 38 and 39 of Aaron 4.
Explore the website http://www.ohio.edu/LINGUISTICS/info/plagiarism.html; discuss how
plagiarism might arise in ECE 4810 and how plagiarism can be completely
avoided. HW #2: DUE 1/18 1.
Read descriptions of previous senior design
projects available at http://www.wmich.edu/engineer/senior-design-conference.htm 2.
Read Characteristics
of an Ideal ECE Senior Design Project 3.
Read Policy on
Patents and Release of Reports 4.
Reread syllabus section on Project Constraints,
and in particular the course policy on accepting only “open” projects HW #3 DUE 1/18 Form
design team and submit memo identifying group members (one memo per group). HW #4: DUE 1/25 Note: As
always, responses to subjective
questions must be justified and demonstrate your mastery of the related
material. 1.
Read Middendorf chapters 6 and 10 2.
Complete Middendorf, CH 1, Review and Discussion,
questions 1, 2, and 3; Middendorf, CH 6, Review and Discussion question 1 3.
Provide two example sentences that are a) first
person active; b) first person passive; c) third person passive; and d) third
person active. Your technical writing text may be useful here or see [Brown
1989]. |
|
2 |
1/11 |
plagiarism (including proper use of quotes in
homework, citing sources, engineering design: needs analysis and
specifications |
WEEK 2 |
||
|
|
1/16 |
Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Day |
|
3 |
1/18 |
engineering design: needs analysis and sources
and types of specifications HWS #1-#3 DUE |
|
WEEK 3 |
||
|
4 |
1/23 |
writing style for engineering documents engineering design: needs analysis and
specifications engineering design: specifications taxonomy |
|
5 |
1/25 |
introduction to engineering design methods engineering design: device evolution HW #4 DUE HW #5 DUE 2/6 1.
Explore www.nssn.org, a “search
engine for standards” 2.
Complete REVIEW
PROBLEM SET as handed out in class. Be sure to follow homework
preparation guidelines as described in the syllabus. 3.
Middendorf CH 3, Review and Discussion, questions
1, 2, 6, 7, 10 4.
Using WMU’s library website, obtain an electronic
copy of the article “Floating a Challenge” by Carlson in Scientific American, vol. 279, issue 5, pgs. 112 and 114,
November 1998. Read (but do not turn in) that article. 5.
Complete PP3.5 6.
Read Middendorf CH 4 up to and including 4.4.1 and
CH 15 |
|
WEEK 4 |
||
|
6 |
1/30 |
project topic application (PTA) engineering design: repeated analysis engineering design: synthesis |
|
7 |
2/1 |
design
methods/plagiarism quiz |
|
WEEK 5 |
||
|
8 |
2/6 |
engineering design: feasibility studies proposal preparation HW #5 DUE HW #6 DUE 2/20 1.
Middendorf, CH 10, Review and Discussion,
questions 2, 10 2.
Complete PP10.100.
Carefully
document your work. Attach a signed statement stating that your results have
been verified and are correct. Assignments will not be accepted without this
statement. 3.
Read Middendorf CH 8 4.
Using WMU’s library website, obtain an electronic
copy of the article “Chilling Tale: GE Refrigerator Woes Illustrate the
Hazards in Changing a Product” by O’Boyle in the May 7, 1990 The Wall Street Journal. Read (but do
not turn in) that article. Prepare a memo describing how feasibility studies
might have avoided the described fallout of developing a new rotary
compressor. |
|
9 |
2/8 |
BRING
A COPY OF YOUR RESUME (ON
A LAPTOP COMPUTER IF POSSIBLE) job search
skills, including “the interview” and resume preparation
|
|
WEEK 6 |
||
|
10 |
2/13 |
planning the design process: precedence
table/matrix work
flow diagrams |
|
11 |
2/15 |
engineering design: view NOVA® video “TO THE MOON,” a
documentary on the Apollo space program. Interested students may find
supplemental information at http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/tothemoon/ |
|
WEEK 7 |
||
|
12 |
2/20 |
discuss NOVA® video “TO THE MOON” HW #6 DUE |
|
13 |
2/22 |
project
planning: CPM project
scheduling: PERT PTA DUE (turn in ONE copy only) with completed
“Project Topic Application Cover Sheet” |
|
|
2/23 |
FE EXAM REGISTRATION DEADLINE |
|
WEEK 8 |
||
|
14 |
2/27 |
project
scheduling: PERT senior design project proposal evaluation
criteria |
|
15 |
2/29 |
review PTAs (instructor meets with
each group) HW #7 DUE 3/19 1.
Read CH 5 Middendorf 2.
Using the WMU library (“IEEE Spectrum”) locate and
read the article “It’s All in Your Head” by Harry Goldstein, IEEE Spectrum, vol. 39, issue 3, pp.
65-68. HW #8 DUE 3/21 PP 8.3.2h (one per group) |
|
WEEK 9 |
||
|
16 |
3/12 |
discuss design methods/plagiarism quiz discuss 8.3.2h and 8.3.2k system
vs. component tolerances discuss exam #1 |
|
17 |
3/14 |
intellectual property |
|
WEEK 10 |
||
|
18 |
3/19 |
LAST DAY TO WITHDRAW intellectual property engineering ethics: introduction Is there absolute
“right” and “wrong”? Who defines moral law? FIRST DRAFT OF PROJECT
PROPOSAL DUE to 4810 instructor Be sure to
attach a proposal evaluation form (“Evaluation Criteria for ECE 4810 Project
Proposals”) as the cover of your proposal; FILL OUT THE PROJECT TITLE AND TEAM MEMBERS on that form. Also TURN IN YOUR GRADED PTA with your
proposal. HW #7 DUE |
|
19 |
3/21 |
engineering ethics HW#8 DUE HW #9 DUE 4/2 1.
Read Middendorf section 1.3 2.
Locate and read IEEE Code of Ethics 3.
Locate and read NSPE Code of Ethics 4.
Explore the engineering ethics cases described at http://ethics.tamu.edu/ethicscasestudies.htm; pick three REAL cases to read in detail HW #10 DUE 4/9 PP 8.3.2k (one per
group) |
|
WEEK 11 |
||
|
20 |
3/26 |
exam preparation (review HW) |
|
21 |
3/28 |
exam preparation (review HW) Practice Problem
10.100 RESUBMIT DUE 4/13 Carefully document your work. Attach a
signed statement stating that your results have been verified and are
correct. Assignments will not be accepted without this statement. |
|
WEEK 12 |
||
|
22 |
4/2 |
engineering ethics HW #9 DUE SECOND DRAFT OF
PROJECT PROPOSAL DUE to 4810 instructor (be sure to include a copy of the proposal evaluation form as the
proposal cover sheet) assign country to each group for HW#13 HW #11 (one per group) DUE 4/11 1.
DM-1 2.
DM-2 HW #12 DUE
4/11 1.
DM-3 2.
DM-4 3.
Register your credentials at broncojobs.wmich.edu |
|
23 |
4/4 |
EXAM #1 (bring “blue book”) |
|
WEEK 13 |
||
|
24 |
4/9 |
view NSPE video
“Gilbane Gold” that describes a fictitious yet realistic engineering ethics
case HW #10 DUE HW #13 DUE 4/16 1.
Prepare
a memo recommending a course of action to the fictitious character David
Jackson featured in the NSPE “Gilbane Gold” video assuming that he has not
yet gone public and the media is unaware of the “problem.” You must use a code of ethics (e.g. IEEE
or NSPE) to justify your response 2.
Read
Middendorf CH 2 |
|
25 |
4/11 |
Joshua Kohnert Career and Student Employment Services in-class presentations of DM-1 and DM-2 HW #11 DUE HW #12 DUE |
|
26 |
4/13 |
FRIDAY FRIDAY FRIDAY 10.100 resubmissions due product liability engineering
registration electronic equipment fabrication techniques |
|
|
4/14 |
FE EXAM |
|
WEEK 14 |
||
|
27 |
4/16 |
final
examination preparation HW #13 DUE |
|
|
4/17 |
TUESDAY: attend at least two ECE presentations at the
senior design conference. Sign
attendance sheet. |
|
28 |
4/18 |
encourage
instructor evaluation participation course
wrap-up FINAL DRAFT OF PROJECT PROPOSAL DUE to 4810
advisor (be sure to include a copy of the proposal evaluation form as the proposal cover sheet); Submit Sponsor
Evaluation and Acknowledgement of Receipt of Final Project Proposal form. See form for instructions before submitting final proposal draft. |
|
WEEK 15 |
||
|
29 |
Monday 4/23 5-7PM |
FINAL EXAM (Bring “blue
book”) |
Credits and
Copyright
Parts
adapted/adopted from syllabi by J. Gesink and J. Kelemen
©
2012 Damon A. Miller. All rights reserved.